Create a free Collision Repair Mag account to continue reading

Renewal split: Ontario approves insurance cuts and increases

Six insurance company logos displayed in a grid: Wawanesa Mutual, Intact Insurance, TD Insurance, Jevco Insurance, Commonwell Mutual Insurance Group, and Echelon Insurance

Ontario's financial regulator has approved auto insurance rate changes for 2027 that will cut premiums for some drivers while raising them for others, depending on their insurer and risk profile. Major carriers like Wawanesa and Intact are cutting rates by up to 4.51%, while high-risk subsidiaries and some standard carriers are raising rates by up to 5.70%, effective starting January 2027.

  • Rate cuts approved: Wawanesa (3.99%), Intact (1.85%), Security National (3.73%), and Primmum (3.88%) all effective January 2027
  • Rate increases approved: TD General (4.51%), Jevco (5.70%), and Echelon (2.86%) taking effect January-March 2027
  • Corporate siblings differ: Intact cuts main brand rates 1.85% while high-risk subsidiary Jevco raises rates 5.70%
  • Your actual premium depends on: driving record, vehicle type, postal code, coverage options, and insurer subsidiary
  • Ontario context: average annual premium was $2,218 as of June 2026; GTA drivers average $2,868

Some Ontario drivers are in line for lower auto insurance premiums early next year, while others will pay more depending on who underwrites their policy.

The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) has signed off on a fresh batch of rate adjustments that will push renewal bills in opposite directions starting in January 2027.

While major insurers like Wawanesa Mutual and Intact Insurance Company have been approved to lower their base rates, high-risk and specialty subsidiaries—along with several standard carriers—are raising prices.

The most recent approvals include a 0.32% average rate cut for Commonwell Mutual and a 2.86% hike for Echelon Insurance, both taking effect on renewals starting March 1, 2027.

The approved adjustments apply to renewals beginning on the following dates:

• Wawanesa Mutual: 3.99% decrease (Jan. 1, 2027)

• Intact Insurance Company: 1.85% decrease (Jan. 7, 2027)

• Security National (TD): 3.73% decrease (Jan. 15, 2027)

• Primmum (TD): 3.88% decrease (Jan. 15, 2027)

• TD General: 4.51% increase (Jan. 15, 2027)

• Jevco (Intact): 5.70% increase (Jan. 28, 2027)

• Commonwell Mutual: 0.32% decrease (March 1, 2027)

• Echelon Insurance: 2.86% increase (March 1, 2027)

Drivers under the same corporate parent can see wildly different outcomes because subsidiaries target different risk profiles. For example, Intact's main brand is cutting rates by 1.85%, while its high-risk subsidiary, Jevco, is hiking rates by 5.70%. Similarly, TD is dropping rates at Security National and Primmum while raising them at TD General.

The approved percentages reflect company-wide averages and do not guarantee an identical change on every driver's bill. Individual premiums still depend on a driver's record, vehicle, postal code and coverage options. Policies renewing before an insurer's effective date will remain on the previous rate schedule.

The mixed rate changes follow years of steep climbs for Ontario motorists. FSRA data shows the province's average annual auto premium hit $2,218 as of June 2026, up $98 from a year earlier, with Greater Toronto Area drivers paying an average of $2,868.

For the collision repair industry, consumer rate cuts do not translate to lower repair payouts. While rising parts and repair bills are factored into the projected claims costs insurers use to justify rate filings, FSRA rate approvals only govern what insurers charge drivers—not what they pay bodyshops to fix vehicles.

Page 1 of 104
Next Page