Create a free Collision Repair Mag account to continue reading

Fraud files: Ontario selects Équité for insurance reporting system

Damaged silver sedan in auto repair shop with insurance documents and car key on table, Toronto skyline visible.

Ontario’s insurance regulator has selected Équité Association to help build a reporting system covering auto insurance fraud, including deliberately inflated repair bills, unnecessary repairs and fraudulent towing charges.

The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) announced the selection Nov. 18.

Équité will support the first phase of its Fraud Reporting Service, which will collect information from insurers to help measure fraud and identify emerging patterns.

Équité is a Toronto-based national not-for-profit organization that works with property and casualty insurers on fraud investigations, vehicle recovery and data analysis. Founded in 2021, it already combines information across insurers to help identify connections that individual companies might miss.

“Auto insurance fraud is becoming increasingly sophisticated and organized, posing a significant risk across Ontario’s auto insurance system and impacting fairness to consumers,” said Jordan Solway, FSRA’s executive vice-president of property and casualty insurance.

The selection advances a project that has been under development for more than two years. FSRA opened consultation on the reporting rule in July 2024. Ontario’s finance minister approved the rule June 3, 2025.

The reporting requirements have not yet taken effect. They depend on the provincial government bringing related Insurance Act amendments into force.

FSRA’s accompanying guidance identifies several activities relevant to collision repair businesses. Examples include intentionally inflating repair costs, repairing areas that do not require work, billing for unnecessary towing and disguising stolen vehicles with another vehicle’s identification number.

The system’s scope also extends to staged collisions, false insurance applications, fake insurance policies and fraud committed by insurance-company employees.

Reporting will require more than an insurer’s suspicion.

FSRA’s guidance says insurers need evidence, verified facts or other information supporting a reasonable belief that fraud has occurred. They will not have to wait for a court finding, but an unusual claim or an unverified tip alone will fall below the reporting threshold.

A report will therefore record an insurer’s evidence-based assessment. It will not, by itself, establish that someone committed fraud.

Once the rule takes effect, insurers will have to submit qualifying information within 45 days after each calendar quarter ends. The obligation applies where an insurer has acted or made a decision based on reasonable grounds to believe fraud occurred.

Insurers must ensure their submissions are complete, current and factually correct. They must correct deficient information and recommend withdrawing information that cannot be corrected or fails to meet the reporting requirements.

The rule also restricts unnecessary disclosure of personal information. Names and identifying details must be removed unless they are necessary for assessing and detecting fraud.

Équité’s selection follows requests from insurers to use its existing capabilities.

FSRA received 15 submissions during its 2024 consultation. In its published summary, the regulator reported that most respondents addressing the service provider considered Équité the best-equipped organization for the work. Some insurers already supplied similar information to Équité and argued that using it could reduce duplicate work and expense.

Respondents also raised concerns about implementation costs, continuing administrative work, privacy and potential litigation arising from reports.

The first phase will establish a collection of information for FSRA’s use. Insurers will not receive access to other companies’ submissions through that phase.

A proposed second phase would allow insurers to access reported information to help detect fraud. FSRA’s consultation response says that expansion would require Ministry of Finance approval and depend on the results of the first phase.

Page 1 of 2019
Next Page